Sarahy’s Scoop: NCAA Week 4 and 5

Locked In and Leveling Up!

Week 5 felt like a turning point. The margin for error is shrinking, the pressure is rising, and programs across the country are starting to separate from the pack. From headline-worthy scores to meets that came down to the final routines, this weekend delivered the intensity that defines NCAA gymnastics. Here are the moments everyone is still talking about.

5. No. 9 Stanford v. California

Stanford is starting to look more and more comfortable on the national stage. In a competitive matchup with California, the Cardinal delivered the kind of performance that signals steady growth rather than fleeting momentum.

Anna Roberts led the meet on beam with a 9.950, while Sienna Robinson matched that number on bars to showcase Stanford’s rising scoring potential. California answered with standout routines of its own, including a 9.900 vault from Kyen Mayhew and a 9.900 on floor from Tonya Paulsson, but what stood out most was the confidence Stanford is beginning to show and build against any opponent If this trajectory continues, the Cardinal won’t stay under the radar for long.

4. No. 1 Oklahoma vs. Kentucky

Oklahoma continues to dominate the national landscape, once again showcasing the depth that has made the Sooners the team to beat. Faith Torrez captured the beam title yet again, while Hannah Scheible, Keira Wells, and Addison Fatta powered the vault lineup with massive 9.9+ scores. Kentucky, however, made the meet one worth watching. 

Delaynee Rodriguez, currently ranked No. 8 in the all-around, took home the title with a career-best 39.550, delivering one of the night’s most complete performances. Creslyn Brose added to the excitement with a 9.950 on floor, her unique and energetic routine serving as a perfect example of the creativity and entertainment value that continue to elevate NCAA gymnastics.

3. No. 5 Penn State vs. No. 7 Illinois

Penn State defended its home floor with a composed performance against Illinois, using steady routines across multiple events to secure the victory. The Nittany Lions were led by Ricky Perez’s winning 13.90 on pommel horse, Luke Esparo’s impressive 14.10 on rings, and Akseli Karsikas’ meet-best 13.70 on high bar.

Illinois delivered standout moments of its own, claiming event titles on floor, vault, and parallel bars. Nathan Whitaker continues to establish himself as a must-watch on floor this season, turning in another attention-grabbing performance. Despite the Illini’s event success, Penn State’s consistency ultimately proved to be the difference-maker.

2. Georgia’s Lily Smith

It seemed impossible for Georgia’s Lily Smith to get any more unforgettable after her viral beam routine atop a 52-story building in New York City — but this weekend, she delivered once again. Known for her traditional, artistic style that sets her apart in a power-heavy NCAA field, Smith anchored the Bulldogs on floor with a flawless 10.0, showcasing beautifully extended lines and polished execution. 

She followed it up with a near-perfect 9.975 on beam as Georgia topped Central Michigan, Temple, and Fisk. The Bulldogs also secured their second meet win of Week 5 with a strong victory over Auburn.

1. No. 3  LSU vs. No. 7 Missouri

As our meet of the week, it’s only right I bring attention to the thriller that was this Tiger matchup. The LSU Tigers took on the Mizzou Tigers in Columbia, Missouri, in a tightly contested SEC battle that came down to the final tenths. Missouri delivered a strong performance and nearly pulled off the upset, highlighted by a massive 49.475 floor rotation, but LSU held its ground to secure its first road win of the season by just .175.

After a quieter bars rotation than expected, LSU rebounded with a powerful showing on vault and a strong 49.55 on floor. Beam brought some late-meet tension, but Kailin Chio sealed the victory with a near-perfect 9.975. Missouri saw standout routines from Railey Jackson on vault and Lauren McPherson on beam, proving the Tigers were more than ready for the showdown.

See our Photo Gallery from the Spouts Collegiate Quad Here!

See the 2026 NCAA Women’s Schedule Here!

See the 2026 NCAA Men’s Schedule Here!

Follow the CGA Here!

Follow @InsideGym for all of the action all season long!

Sarahy Mora Rincon is a Communications and Media Arts & Design double major at James Madison University. The Richmond, Virginia native serves as president of JMU Club Gymnastics, where she helps lead the team and support its events, outreach, and involvement in the collegiate club gymnastics community.

Photos by Lloyd Smith for Inside Gymnastics; University of Michigan

ROAD TO NATIONALS RANKINGS

Subscribe to Inside Gymnastics for 3 Years and receive a free gift!